Pizza restaurants

New York Pizzeria aka Slices

4.5 128 reviews 4:00 AM - 8:00 PM 39 Lebanon St, Hamilton, NY 13346, United States

Discover this place

New York Pizzeria, also known as Slices, has carved out a special place in the hearts of Hamilton residents. Located at 39 Lebanon St, this pizza restaurant has gained a loyal following for its excellent offerings and reasonable prices. Customers rave about the mouth-watering pizza; Jake Lutke emphasizes that it’s the best in the area. The slices are available for just $1.75, an unbeatable deal for such quality, with quick service that keeps patrons coming back. The menu extends beyond pizza, featuring BBQ wings that LeRoy Burly endorses as fantastic, especially when paired with a drink for only $22. Each visit guarantees a satisfying meal, with Andre Nash noting the option for thin crust, catering to diverse palates. Though the dining room may need a refresh, the focus remains squarely on the food. Each bite is celebrated, with Fred Monroe declaring his pizza delicious and just as he expected. With its combination of value, quality, and convenience, New York Pizzeria aka Slices is undoubtedly a must-visit for any pizza lover in Hamilton. It's a beloved gem that delivers not just good food, but a fulfilling experience.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Dinner
Counter service
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd

College students
Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with New York Pizzeria aka Slices before visiting.

Reviews for New York Pizzeria aka Slices

4.5

128 reviews

100%

30%

Review highlights

Based on 128 reviews

New York Pizzeria aka Slices in Hamilton is widely appreciated for its flavorful, high-quality pizza offered at very competitive prices. Customers often highlight the convenience of quick service and the availability of both dine-in and takeaway options. The menu’s standout feature includes affordable, customizable slices, including thin crust varieties. While the atmosphere receives occasional remarks about needing updates, this does not detract from the overall positive dining experience. Patrons commonly praise the friendly service and consider it one of the best pizza spots in the area, frequently returning for both the food quality and value.

Jake Lutke

May 15, 2025

Great pizza! Great price! Great couple! This is the best pizza in the Hamilton area. I haven't had anything else off the menu, so I can't vouch for that. The dining room could use a refresh, but it doesn't take away from the food.

LeRoy Burly

Apr 30, 2025

I got a small pizza and 10 BBQ wings and a drink for 22. You can't find that kind of price anywhere these days. And to make it even better, the food was fantastic. Will definitely be a returning customer.

Danny Jerome

Apr 22, 2025

Probably the best pizza I've ever had. It's so convenient and all around the best pizza place around. A slice is 1.75 and is ready right away, and if it isn't, will be in under a minute. Great place to sit down or pickup.

ANDRE NASH

Mar 30, 2025

We sometimes buy pizzas here for dinner. And you can get them with thin crust!

Fred Monroe

Mar 28, 2025

Tonight’s pizza was delicious! Exactly as i expected.

Melinda Ho

Feb 25, 2025

The cheese pizza slice taste the same, and the prices are still the same as it was 14 years ago! This place has not changed one bit. They still sell the “slices come plain only” tshirt too for 10. NY pizza slices at its finest and for 2/slice. Colgate staple. Highly recommend.

elite9800

Feb 20, 2025

Its football pizza for sure. It's a solid 7.2 and the price can't be beat. There a good family owned business good people good food good prices

Roger & Alyssa Belush

Feb 06, 2025

Always great to pop in to grab a quick slice of pizza for dinner between sports. It's the cheapest on the block, never disappoints, and the staff is the best. They also have the best wings at a phenomenal price.